Saturday, October 22, 2005

gaudy comment by gowda


Hey..

So Deve Gowda opened his mouth and we saw a typical IT professional reaction from NR Narayana Murthy, Chief Mentor of Infosys.

As I always keep saying Narayana Murthy is the "Gandhi for Indian IT". Coming from a very simple background and a strong belief in socialism, Murthy had built the Indian IT giant Infosys almost entirely on his own skill, acumen and confidence. Inspite of all his success, his "father of Indian IT services" status, multi million dollars locked up in his bank accounts, controlling a staff of over 50,000, meeting heads of state of almost every country in the world - the man still leads a simple life, trying to help the society in whatever way he can - thus being a perfect role model for the IT youngsters who havent found an ideal politician whom they could emulate.

The stories of Murthy's simplicity are popular everywhere. It is said that when his son at college was asked what his father does for a living, he simply replied - "My father's name is Murthy. He works for Infosys.". Infosys and Murthy have taken very good care and precaution not only to do a brand building for the company Infosys, but also image building for the Chairman - Narayana Murthy as well. After all, amongst Tatas, Wipros, Satyams, HCLs who were born with silver spoons already - Murthy was the only man to have risen from the ground.

While Chandrababu Naidu was trying to steer his Titanic in the Indian IT wave late 90s with help of Satyam Computer founders (the Byrrajus), Microsoft and Oracle, erstwhile Chief Minister of Karnataka SM Krishna rode the wave primarily with support from Narayana Murthy. When it was felt that IT customers were moving away from the Indian silicon valley - Bangalore- to other destinations like Hyderabad and Chennai, it was primarily Infosys that stuck it out to try & retain the glory back. SM Krishna did a pretty good job at his state to the satisfaction of Madam Sonia and was promptly rewarded with the governorship of Maharashtra.

To his part, Narayana Murthy, who became the towering personality & a symbol of Indian IT early 2000s, he started representing the country in several sectors where there was a win-win for both the state/nation and IT as well. Narayana Murthy had long crossed the borders of just being the Chairman of Infosys and became the equivalent of Gandhi for Indian IT world. And one such project where his leadership was expected was in the BIAL - the Bangalore Intl Airport Limited.

HD Deve Gowda (and I keep forgetting which party he belongs to every time- I wonder if he remembers) of JD(S) and Dharam Singh formed a opportunistic coalition and been running the state with SM Krishna, who declares himself as the man who saved the Karnataka Congress, butting in as much as he can inspite of his constitutional post. Deve Gowda has been leveling charges against Krishna trying destabilize the Dharam Singh government and the comment against Murthy is one of such attacks.

To his credit, Murthy, a typical IT person, with no taste for government bureaucracies, redtape and having a no-nonsense attitude reacted the same way Gowda expected him to do. Murthy resigned right away blasting Deve Gowda and the Karnataka state govt.
I wish he had asked me personally before going to the press, or talked to you or ascertained it from members of the board. I am disappointed that a former prime minister did not accord me this basic courtesy.

I am pained, more so, that leaders in the government like you did not even clarify my role in the company and the work that has been done. I have spent enormous amount of time and energy in interacting with the government in New Delhi and the government here to make this work. The records prove themselves.

Gowda did not stop here and went on accusing Infosys as a company questioning what values it bought to the state after amassing so much of land in and around Bangalore. Infosys retorted strongly with lots of data on the employment opportunities etc., Dharam Singh persuaded Murthy to stay back at BIAL stating that Murthy was a key person in Indian IT - note that not once has the chief minister complimented any work done in the BIAL by the Infosys chairman. A frustrated Murthy was even more pissed and refused the offer.

Perhaps Murthy does not understand. He is dealing with politicians. And that too politicians like Deve Gowda who survive in this world inspite of being themselves. These are people who play with real people as pawns on the political chessboard. Murthy was just one pawn. How can a pawn gain more power than the queen ? Murthy's personality is so threatening to several parties already that there is a long queue of leaders outside his house to rope him in with one of their parties. In the world of youth, people remember HD Deve Gowda as the man who slept in public meetings on stage and not even as a former prime minister. On the other side Narayana Murthy is being virtually worshipped and is more powerful than several Chief Ministers themselves.

It was just a political attack and not a personal one on Mr.Murthy. When he volunteers himself in this part of the world, he has to stay put. His leaving BIAL will benefit no one. While an angry outburst is not unwarranted or unexpected from him, he cant run away from this. He will face hardships - that is the way these things go - and this man of all is not a man who shuns challenges. India needs volunteers & visionaries like him. Sometimes we have to put up with crap, but so be it - every visionary had to. Deve Gowda and people of his sort have to be ignored. They have lost grounds and are barking with no purpose.

Havent we heard a gazillion times Winners never quit and Quitters never win ?.

Ciao..

12 comments:

Sunday Thoughts said...

Good One Siva,
I am expecting a post on this topic for the last three days, as you are the right person to comment about this issue. Even I feel like writing blog about this issue but You, Raman or Eswar are more perfect for this topic. Your expectations from Mr.Murthy are same as I felt. He should not get fumbled for these petty things. When he is dealing with politicians he shouldn’t care about these good for nothing politicians.
And your comment to Anandkumar for Eswar blog is great. Kalakintinga Thalaiva
I donno abcd about Formula one, so sorry for not commenting

Rags said...

What a pity, There are still souls on earth who take Gowda's words seriously...

Murthy Sir, Consider Gowda's words as Rat's ass and get on with the work...

eyeStreet times said...

I was hoping Deve Gowda would see reason and beat a hasty retreat but the moron has the guts to continue his volley of shots at Mr. Murthy.

One things is for sure, the IT people are not going to vote for JD(S) where J stands for Jokers, D for Deve Gowda and (S) stands for Stupid!!

Ganesh said...

Siva nice one.
Gowda the thoongumunchi ,thookathila sonna olarala poi serious eduthikitta eppadi

Krish said...

Don't these politicians realize that the ultimate sufferer is the common man? When capable people are at the helm of a project, the least they can do is keep their mouth shut and not throw a wrench into the works by incendiary comments.

Anonymous said...

eshwar,

Ofcourse IT ppl won't vote for Gowda next time around.

The (sad) facts:
- Almost all of IT population in Karnata is in Bangalore.
- More than 50% of IT folks (including myself) *do not* vote at all.
- The IT folks that do vote, are mostly from Karnataka.
- And Deve Gowda is doing enough to appease Karnataka IT work force (save Murthy) already.
- Deve Gowda is not too keen to win Bangalore local body election, his target is the state legislative body election.

Result:
All his actions aren't going to "cost" him in any way (remember, his goal is "to win state elections").

Anonymous said...

Hi All,

I'm not sure whether yall know this already.

Last week (after Gowda-Murthy spat), central govt (to be precide, Civil Aviation Minister, Mr. Proful Patel) severely criticize BAIL with respect to the design of the proposed airport and have ordered them to redesign (which is being done by BAIL right now).

Since we all talk about Murthy resigning from BAIL, what role was Murthy playing so far? Why did the design screw up big time? Who is resposible (of course, the architects, but they work on the inputs from their bosses!)? Does the chairman own any responsibility?

I know this is not what Gowda accused Murthy off. But, won't BAIL be better of with a chairman who can spend time on it more than what Murthy can possibly do?

- Anand

Shiva said...

Tharani - thanks Sir. :) And I always look fwd to reading your Sunday thoughts every Saturday :)

Rags - yeah..

Eshwar - Deve Gowda seeing reason ? You must be kidding..

Shiva said...

Dinesh Babu - you are right!

Ganesh - correct.. thideernu thookathula ezhundu etho solraar gowda.. idha poi seriousaa eduthukitta eppadi :)

Thennavan - yep!

Shiva said...

Ananda -

interesting thought line on Murthy's effectiveness as a BIAL chariman. It was his leadership that was soughted for the proj, but if it hadnt paid off effectively, then maybe it is something to think about. Also we need to see what is the relation between Praful Patel and Dharam & Co.

One thing is true though.. this is not about effective leadership or project execution. It is politics anyway and Gowda has ensured votes with this blast of Infosys and the claim for 30% reservation for Kannadigas in Bangalore IT organizations - in a sense he has even ensured Kannada IT voters - even if they are a small percentage.

Anonymous said...

I am surprised that not many of you probably read some of Deve Gowda's questions Q-1 Infosys has requested for 845 acres of land very close to Bangalore without making optimum use of the land already alloted. Please check the validity of the request. Infosys has been silent on this issue. For a company known for precision the answers are way off the mark(very vague) giving rise to all kinds of suspicion about Infosys's real intentions. I request everybody to pay attention to the real issues and discuss them instead of attacking the concerned individuals personally.

Anonymous said...

Who knows where to download XRumer 5.0 Palladium?
Help, please. All recommend this program to effectively advertise on the Internet, this is the best program!